What is legitimate interest?
I could spend a whole blog post just explaining the concept of legitimate interest, so for the purposes of this post, I’ll try to shorten it. Essentially, It’s the idea that you have a reasonable reason to process the data which someone would reasonably expect, and that is ethical and legal.
Now there is a lot more to it than that, and you can read more about this on the ICO website which includes the full three-part consideration test that you should use to evaluate your legitimate interest reasoning (if you choose to use this as your basis for processing – more on that in a moment).
If you can justify legitimate interest for your grounds for processing, in the case of opt-in forms this means that you may not need a checkbox to conform to GDPR.
What is consent?
The idea of consent is seemingly clearer than the idea of legitimate interest, and yet it is still open to much interpretation.
In terms of GDPR, consent is a clear, affirmative action to give permission to processing.
For the purposes of opt-in forms and landing pages, this could be the action of inputting an email into a form and clicking submit, or it could be checking a box next to confirm agreement to a privacy message or condition under your form. These are all types of consent.
So what does all this mean for your opt-in forms?
Well the first thing to note is, if you can justify legitimate interest as your grounds for processing the data (i.e. collecting it on your opt-in form and then sending up follow-up emails) then this could mean you do not need a checkbox on your forms.
It’s important to note that although it might sound like the easy option here – you do need to have a solid evaluation of your reasoning for legitimate interest and have this well documented in case of any kind of audit or investigation. Not all situations will fit legitimate interest grounds so this shouldn’t be used as a one-size fits all solution.
A few steps to consider if you plan to use legitimate interest as your grounds for processing on opt-in forms:
- I’d highly recommend you get the GDPR Pack from Suzanne Dibble which includes a legitimate Interest assessment (as mentioned earlier) and review each of your forms/landing pages/opt-ins.
- Keep a clearly documented record of the outcome and your reasoning for each opt-in in the legitimate interest assessment form (this obviously needs to meet the requirements of legitimate interest to use this)
- Ensure you review the assessment if you change the nature of your processing in the future
- Remember that you must give prospects/subscribers the “right to object” at any time – so have clear unsubscribe/opt-out links on all emails and throughout the process. You may also want to highlight this in a privacy message below your forms.
- You must clearly tell individuals what your grounds for processing is (include this in your privacy policy. You could include some text like “When we offer you reports and other items of value which are offered for free, we are relying on legitimate interest to send you marketing communications”. You should link to this privacy policy in a notice located close to your form (most likely you will place this in notice under your form submit button).
- Keep all opt-in form wording as clear as possible – make it crystal clear what the individual is subscribing to and what they will be sent after opt-in. It’s advisable to include information that you will send marketing emails (or whatever you plan to do) in copy somewhere on your opt-in form – perhaps in the copy with the privacy link below the submit button.
How to get consent on your opt-in forms
If you’re not comfortable with using legitimate Interest as your grounds for collecting emails and marketing to your audience, you’ll need to rely on the basis of consent.
Using consent as your grounds for processing means that you are seeking a clear affirmative consent from the individual for any data processing you plan to initiate after the opt-in.
Before you immediately think that you need to add a ton of checkboxes below your forms, remember that the act of submitting your opt-in form (entering an email and submitting the form) is a clear affirmative action. So you should consider how you can word the copy around your opt-in form to indicate that your visitor is giving consent through the submission of their email.
For example: Let’s say I had a bonsai tree training business and wanted to send out a newsletter to my audience each week with bonsai news and the occasional promotion. I could potentially use a form like this:
39 replies to "OptimizePress & GDPR: A Practical Guide to Compliance [UPDATED]"
The GDPR options on the Optimizepress Plugin seems to have a lot of issues. I spent a great deal of time trying to set it up as you can see on this video to no avail. So if any of you guys are having similar issues please report it to the tech support guy. Maybe after hearing it from a few of us he will look into it with an open mind that it may be a bug on the app (Note: bug is a funny term used by tech guys that refers usually to an error made by the programmer).
https://youtu.be/60RN-bFqNLg
What happens with Google Fonts & Optimizepress? How can we solve this issue?
Can you confirm which version of OptimizePress the GDPR options will be in? I have V2.153
Did you try the “label span, legend span” CSS options? I’ve not tested this myself but it might work for now.
Update to 2.5.15
Hi Travis, the GDPR checkboxes are for GDPR content. Try our Privacy Policy Plugin for what you need.
Guys, am I taking crazy pills? The new forms aren’t GDPR compliant whatsoever… if the “I agree to the Privacy Policy” is not REQUIRED to be checked, then the user is not agreeing, and his data is still being taken and tracked. In it’s current form, you’re going to get us fined 2% of our yearly income. If the box is NOT CHECKED, they should be getting a pop up that says, “Hey… you need to agree to the Privacy Policy to continue”. Right now, that is not happening. Please fix this.
Ok for the Checkbox for optin, but how to register the user’s consent or the fact that flag the checkbox? Please Help Me. We use GetResponse as autoresponder and i see in the document that there’isnt
Hey Ryan! Thanks for stopping by. Always a pleasure to have you grace us with your presence 🙂
Thanks for the feature request. We’ll look into those. Emoji’s might be an option at server level character encoding set. I’ll dig around for that. Also there might be a plugin that support it inside form fields. Obviously it’s in WordPress as we can use it here 🙂
Oh! and #3… how about the ability to change the text color? The optin right at the top of my homepage has a colored background, so the black text gets washed out quite a lot 🙁
Hey guys! Awesome as per usual. Two pertinent questions for you.
1. Will there be (or is there) the ability to control the order/placement of where the checkbox is within an opt-in? For example, I’d love to place the checkbox above the CTA button so that more people actually read it and consider opting in for additional content.
2. Could you guys please add emoji support to the text field for the privacy notice? Hoping to add an emoji there to make it stand out more to readers and encourage more people to consider opting in. When I pop an emoji in there now, it just throws me a bunch of ?????? after updating the live page.
Thanks for the all around fantastic update guys! 🙂
Hi,
great conten!
Is the data processing agreement ready for us to sign and download?
Greetings!
Hey Marc, OptimizeMember is a plugin of OptimizePress. You would make sure you own site is compliant. OptimizeMember would only use the registration forms of WordPress.
That was a typo Peter! It now reads “We will not sell your information to third parties…”
Hey, great summary! What about optimizemember, is this also GDPR-compliant. Need to know that soon since I have secured my membership area with the help of OP member 🙂
Hi, I leave in Italy and so, sorry for my bad english.
Here is time 10:04 PM of 23 May.
I write for Checkbox GDPR compliant, news for this?
Another day and game over.
Thanks for your answer,
Marco
Thanks a lot,
this is very useful feature, by the way, may I ask you in which way I can investigate in case of customers complains?
Are there any log that can be used as a proof of previous ticked optin as a response to the specific GDPR disclaimer?
Mauro
Hey Amy. GDPR does state that you can’t force consent to marketing emails.
However some people say entering your name and email is enough consent… (no check box needed).
I would suggest using double optin for all lists and make it clear what your emails are about. Double should be enough consent to allow you to followup emails.
Again, don’t quote me on this. It’s not legal advice. If people want your email they’ll have no problem agreeing to your policies and giving consent.
Hey Mauro,
When the checkbox is ticked and submitted it will add the info as a tag or custom field in your email provider. This could act as a log for proof if ever needed.
We’re an online retailer in the uk and I’m wondering if we need to get re-consent. When customers placed the order the tick box to subscribe to the mailing list was pre ticked. Plus any eBay sales were automatically added to the mailing list as there’s no way to give them an opt in at the time of placing an order. So do I need to get reconsent? Or can I conclude that because they placed an order they have shown legitimate interest?
Thanks!
That’s what we aimed for 🙂
We will sell your information to third parties as you wrote in the Selina Soo example is probably not risky, but what customer would want to sign this? So I’m hoping it’s just a typo and not a suggestion.
Thank you! I’m looking forward to seeing the updates so I can make my optin forms GDPR compliant.
No problem!
As above, some people are saying placing an order is enough consent to receive emails. I’ve read some privacy policies recently that read exactly that. Did your Policy states this?
However that said, if the boxes were pre-ticked it’s not like they had a choice.
If you have been emailing those people regularly they would have unsubscribed by now if you made it easy to do so.
For future orders you should follow up with an email asking if they want to join your email list and receive future offers, promotions and news etc.
In that follow up email you have a big buttons saying “Yes Join” or “Yes I Give Consent”
So the process is:
Customer places order > Receives service/order emails > You add to mailing list software > Send email asking for consent to.
Thank you. I have a few customers in Europe, randomly, and am based in the US. Couldn’t I have a special double opt-in type message that goes to only European IP addresses that says they understand they will be getting the following emails from me and they need to click the link to proceed? If they don’t confirm their opt-in, then they aren’t approved to get emails. I hate making the checkbox form required for my big majority of US customers.
Thank you; this was clear and comprehensive 🌺
Hi David, Thanks for you input.
1. Not sure if there’s a question her or just a rant? 🙂
2. If someone has given you consent to send them marketing emails then you can email them. I’m sure if you’ve had double optin enable prior to GDPR that can be classed as consent.
This is not legal advice.
I believe if you have a clear policy, explain how you store date, what companies you use, how you track data and you make it easy for someone to contact you to request data/request removal of data, then you are being transparent enough.
Make it easy for people to unsubscribe from all your emails.
If you run an ethical business and show how you use data you have nothing to worry about. Lets see what happens over the next few months.
Thank you. I’ll wait for the new forms
First of all: thank you for this overview.
Here some thoughts:
1) While you provided us with great details about what has to happen on the *fron* end, what needs to happen on the *back* end was only mentioned as a side note (you link to a GDPR package, and you state above “Step 7: Build a Data Inventory – this means anywhere you obtain and process data”. Maybe I am wrong, but since I am actually working on GDPR compliance with an expert (a certified data protection officer), I do know that the documentation part on the backend is quite the undertaking! So, here’s my personal take: In order to be on the safe side, I guess it’s only the second best option to do that based on a package you can buy, because you will have questions. no doubt. Who will answer these? The person that sold the package? If so. good, if not: not good. Because how will you know then that you are truly compliant? Either way: the amount of work that goes into documenting your processes will take time (meaning: you need to think about where you get in touch with personal data, and then you have to *document* it (as in: write down), so you can show that in case of an audit). It’s questionable, of course, if and when you’ll be ever subject to such an audit, but who knows… So, for sure, getting the frontend aspects up and running may seem to have the highest priority, but for the sake of all those business owners out there, I wish there’d be more emphasis on stressing the documentation part – because I believe many people are simply not aware of it, or of its full scope.
2) Regarding being specific what you want to send people: Can’t I simply write that they will be contacted by me via email? This would then include everything.
3) I do agree with the aspect of this being a chance to cleanse our email lists.
Best regards
David
Really useful article – thanks guys! Now need to get started on implementing all this
Thank you James – this is so helpful!
The GDPR options on the Optimizepress Plugin seems to have a lot of issues. I spent a great deal of time trying to set it up as you can see on this video to no avail. So if any of you guys are having similar issues please report it to the tech support guy. Maybe after hearing it from a few of us he will look into it with an open mind that it may be a bug on the app (Note: bug is a funny term used by tech guys that refers usually to an error made by the programmer).
The GDPR options on the Optimizepress Plugin seems to have a lot of issues. I spent a great deal of time trying to set it up as you can see on this video to no avail. So if any of you guys are having similar issues please report it to the tech support guy. Maybe after hearing it from a few of us he will look into it with an open mind that it may be a bug on the app (Note: bug is a funny term used by tech guys that refers usually to an error made by the programmer).
Hi Alex, please contact our support team for that one 🙂
What is that plugging? has it additional cost? and how can I put the link to redirect to my privacy policy page?
Hey Carlos, have you reached out to our support team about this. I’m sure they can assist.